Social Media Twitter Facebook Linked In RSS Feed Podcasts
Login

One of the most keenly-anticipated sessions at the recent annual meeting of the Sustainable Apparel Coalition’s (SAC) in Singapore brought together different sides of the ongoing controversy over the use of data from the Higg Index suite of tools on consumer-facing product labels.

Representatives of Higg, the Norwegian Consumer Authority (NCA) and Norwegian brand Norrøna sought to exchange ideas on the best way for fashion companies to inform consumers of the environmental impacts of their products.

Back in June, the SAC suspended the use of Higg Materials Sustainability Index (MSI) data on product labels after the NCA concluded that Norrøna's claims were likely to be in breach of Norway's Marketing Control Act. The NCA also issued a warning to Swedish fashion giant H&M. In his written report on the Norrøna case, NCA head of section Tonje Drevland said: "As far as we understand, the real reason behind the substantial reduction in water consumption in global average numbers is because organic cotton farms typically are located in places with more rainfall compared to most conventional cotton farms."

Chief among their gripes was the use of lifecycle analysis (LCA) reports, containing global averages for environmental impact. This had led Norrøna to claim that an organic cotton t-shirt required the use of 87 per cent less water than one made of conventional cotton. NB: In the magazine version of this article, an annotation at this point on the page noted: “Technically, this was accurate but only because organic cotton tends to be grown in parts of the world, such as India, that require little or no irrigation.”

Subsequently, the SAC has also announced it is undertaking a third-party review of Higg MSI data and methodology but the controversy has continued to rumble on, with the NCA, together with the Dutch Authority for Consumer and Markets (ACM), issuing joint guidance on a way forward for the industry.

On the panel at Singapore sat the SAC’s vice president of the Higg Index, Jeremy Lardeau; the NCA’s head of section, Tonje Drevland; Norrøna’s chief sustainability officer Brad Boren; and Textile Exchange’s chief executive La Rhea Pepper.

Drevland’s message was that sustainability information directed at consumers needed to be clear and accurate.

“I want H&M, Inditex, all large players to take a step back and realise that the steps they are taking internally may feel hugely costly to them but remember to look at it from the other side, from the environmental perspective,” she said.

“Consumer information is great but be sure that you have the correct data and that you know that you're on the right path and be sure to put the data and the claims into context for the consumer. What does it mean?”

Lardeau welcomed the NCA’s input and accepted the need for better data, before alluding to ongoing efforts at the SAC to address these very problem areas.

“It's a very complicated space and I think we have to recognise that. I think the guidance is a step in the right direction,” he said, adding:

I think we recognise the need to have clear substantiated, not overblown claims of sustainability performance. I also agree that this guidance raises the urgency around the need for better data, better methodologies.

But he also called for consistency from policy makers, with consumer protection chiefs in Norway declaring the use of Higg MSI data for product labels illegal under EU legislation, while the French environmental ministry was using similar data to develop a similar service for consumers.

The NCA and the ACM insist their 11-page guidance on how the fashion industry should share sustainability information with consumers is based on their interpretation of EU law. However, it is not legally binding and the SAC is consulting with its lawyers on how best to respond.

Drevland told Ecotextile News: "We hope this guidance makes it easier for the textile industry to make clear and accurate environmental claims to consumers," saying that:

It is not all that difficult - make sure you have documentation for your claims, do not exaggerate and take a step back and consider how your marketing may be perceived by a consumer with little to no knowledge of the industry.

Both the NCA and the ACM have been active in seeking out greenwashing in the fashion industry. While the NCA investigated Norrøna's claims, the ACM's inquiries led H&M to temporarily withdraw its 'Conscious' and 'Conscious Choice' labels, and Decathlon to do the same with its 'Ecodesign' label.

Edwin van Houten, director of ACM’s consumer department, said: “We find it positive that the clothing industry is committed to making the environmental impact of its materials more transparent for consumers. This helps consumers make more sustainable choices."

But he added: "It is important that they do so properly so that consumers are not misled. With these guidelines, we explain how businesses can do just that."

Global averages

In the document, the watchdogs say it should be made clear if the numbers presented in sustainability claims are global averages. And, in those cases, it must be made very clear to the consumer that the numbers are not directly related to a specific product.

They also pointed out that Higg MSI data was based on a “cradle to gate” assessment of the environmental impacts of a material from raw materials to finished product – but did not measure impact across the entire life cycle of a product.

"This will not be self-explanatory to the average consumer," continues the guidance. "Therefore, the SAC also needs to make clear to consumers what the measuring of environmental impacts only 'cradle to gate' means."

The guidance also added that most consumers would not realise that Higg MSI data was only intended to compare different types of the same material – such as organic and conventional cotton.

"This should also be made clear to the consumer," it says. "Otherwise, consumers could be misled to believe that a comparison of environmental impact across different types of materials has been made."

And it added that all of this information should be presented in a clear and unambiguous way. It would not be sufficient to simply add lines and lines of extra text which could overload the consumer with information.

NCA director Trond Rønningen said that what had started out as an investigation of the marketing practices of one outdoor product manufacturer had resulted in important guidance for the entire industry.

"As long as you can substantiate your marketing claims and present your message in a way that is clear, concise and understandable for the average consumer, you should be in the clear," he said.

The SAC responded in a statement in which it said it was at one with the watchdogs on the need for environmental information shared with consumers by apparel and footwear brands to be credible, accurate and substantiated.

"Only by the industry working together with policy makers and regulators can the scale of the change that is needed be achieved," it said.

"To assist the industry in moving forward, we need harmonised regulations and clear, coordinated information on how information can be presented to consumers.

“Our ambition, following the next phase of collaboration with the NCA and the European Commission, is to provide guidance for our members, and the wider industry, to ensure all environmental claims are as robust as possible."

To subscribe to our market-leading news, analysis and other content on environmental issues in the fashion sector – including access to our popular mobile app and back issue archive – please follow this link HERE.

Exclusive Insight

  • Thursday, 28 March 2024

    Tracking sustainability through the supply chain Premium Article

    Despite ongoing political wrangling, the European Union’s (EU) Corporate Sustainability Due Diligence Directive (CSDDD) looks like it will finally make it into the statute book - albeit with significant concessions. But what’s this new directive…
  • Wednesday, 27 March 2024

    Are textile innovators hitting the wrong target? Premium Article

    Are fashion brands really the best customers for textile innovators, asks Katherine Albertson, a former project manager with a US bio-based materials pioneer. Renewcell’s declaration of bankruptcy was sad, but hardly shocking. That appears to be the…
  • Wednesday, 27 March 2024

    Fashion’s future fragmented fabric landscape Premium Article

    Last week’s Fashion for Good event in The Netherlands became a frontline for contrasting visions and opinions about the future of existing and next-generation materials used in the fashion sector. Will there be a return to natural fibres?…
  • Tuesday, 26 March 2024

    Renewcell - when risk doesn’t equal reward Premium Article

    With the deadline for offers for bankrupt textile-to-textile recycling pioneer Renewcell less than 48 hours away, Ecotextile News editor John Mowbray argues that the Swedish company's collapse was down to a failure by brands, investors and the…
  • Monday, 25 March 2024

    Haute couture capital sets sights on fast fashion Premium Article

    Baptiste Carriere-Pradal, co-founder of the 2BPolicy consultancy, considers the ambitions of Paris to move on from being the capital of fashion to become a beacon for fashion legislation. For nearly two decades, France has been toying with the idea…
  • Tuesday, 13 February 2024

    Spilling the dirt on compostable stretch denim Premium Article

    Italian textile manufacturer Candiani has shared details of an experiment to show off the compostable qualities of what it claims is the world's first biodegradable stretch denim. A visit to his local butcher in Milan gave Alberto Candiani the idea…
  • Monday, 12 February 2024

    California’s climate of disclosure Premium Article

    With California's newly-implemented climate disclosure laws said to be the most wide-ranging introduced so far, we take a look at what they will mean for businesses. There’s no doubt as to the alarming impact of climate change in the US state – with…
  • Saturday, 10 February 2024

    Why decarbonisation depends on data Premium Article

    HONG KONG – With 2024 already here, it’s too late for any one organisation to roll out a strategy that can guarantees the whole textile sector can reduce its carbon emissions by 45% in the next seven years – a figure called for by scientists if the…
  • Friday, 09 February 2024

    Fashion’s fake GHG emission claims Premium Article

    Lutz Walter, secretary general of the European Technology Platform for the Future of Textiles, outlines why the claim that the fashion industry is to blame for 10% of global greenhouse gas emissions is wrong – and why this matters. Four years after…
  • Thursday, 08 February 2024

    'Industry first' microplastics test developed Premium Article

    Italian textile manufacturer Aquafil has developed what it claims is the first methodology to precisely measure the quality and quantity of microplastics released in the textile industry. The company says the method, developed in partnership with…
  • Wednesday, 07 February 2024

    New tool counts textile process CO2 emissions Premium Article

    A new tool from the Apparel Impact Institute will be able to help calculate the cumulative CO2 emissions for each process and sub-process from textile manufacturing – an industry first. On the 22nd February, we will broadcast the first of a 3-part…
  • Tuesday, 16 January 2024

    Brands' integrity on energy rated 'shallow' Premium Article

    BERLIN – The integrity of the renewable electricity commitments of fashion giants H&M, Zara owner Inditex, Nike, Gap and Lululemon has been found wanting by a new report from the New Climate Institute. The non-profit assessed brands' renewable…
  • Tuesday, 02 January 2024

    Regenerative cotton – don't believe all the hype Premium Article

    Simon Ferrigno argues that regenerative cotton is about local solutions, designed by and with local people, and sold at a price that they can live on. Not a system where cotton producers are constantly observed by new digital tools and data owners,…
  • Thursday, 21 December 2023

    Expert panel talks ESG in fashion Premium Article

    With environmental, social and governance (ESG) investment currently in the doldrums, a panel of experts explain what this could mean for the fashion and retail sectors after its politicisation in the USA; and after UK investors shy away from this…
  • Tuesday, 19 December 2023

    Blanket PFAS ban poses textiles conundrum Premium Article

    The world of eco-textiles is littered with issues that are not clear cut, where there are pluses and minuses, and where compromise rules as stakeholders seek a ‘least bad outcome’ or a reduced environmental impact. But, a blanket ban on PFAS would…
  • Monday, 11 December 2023

    Back to the future for cotton Premium Article

    David Styles speaks to a firm that works with the European Space Agency, Cotton made in Africa and a geospatial technology specialist to explore why satellite imagery is being used to remotely monitor cotton crops. Is this the next phase of the…
  • Thursday, 07 December 2023

    GFA Monitor - many voices, one mission Premium Article

    DUBAI - Launched at COP28 climate summit, the 2023 GFA Monitor is the second edition of a multi-agency report from the Global Fashion Agenda (GFA) that aims to combine the expertise of leading industry bodies across the fashion and textiles…
  • Wednesday, 06 December 2023

    New report links global brands to forced labour Premium Article

    SHEFFIELD - Thirty nine global brands and retailers are at "high risk" of selling goods with exposure to Uyghur forced labour onto the European market, according to a new study. The report, entitled ‘Tailoring Responsibility: Tracing Apparel Supply…
  • Tuesday, 05 December 2023

    Woolly thinking? Premium Article

    OPINION - The Woolmark Company's ongoing campaign against synthetic textiles appears to be full of contradictions A recent LinkedIn post by Livia Firth, the co-founder and creative director of the Eco-Age PR and lobbying agency, on a new campaign…
  • Monday, 04 December 2023

    Are influencers authentic on sustainable fashion? Premium Article

    Influencing by definition is not new, but never before has it been so easy for an average “nobody” to join a social media platform, garner a following and turn themselves into a self-made ‘sustainable fashion influencer’. Tom Bithell explores. 
  • Monday, 04 December 2023

    A rallying cry for next gen materials Premium Article

    If it's true that you know who your real friends are when the chips are down, then Nicole Rycroft, the founder and executive director of Canopy, is a real friend of Renewcell, in particular, and the next gen materials sector in general,…
  • Friday, 01 December 2023

    Textile Exchange production report unpacked Premium Article

    LONDON - Textile Exchange's 10th annual Materials Market Report, formerly the Preferred Fiber and Materials Market Report, paints something of a bleak picture of the industry's sustainability efforts. It found that global fibre production increased…
  • Monday, 27 November 2023

    Ecosystex - bridging the innovation gap Premium Article

    More than 100 stakeholders from 16 countries converged on Barcelona for the first conference of the Ecosystex coalition of research and industry experts involved in EU-funded innovation projects for textile sustainability. Launched earlier this…
  • Tuesday, 21 November 2023

    What's gone wrong at Renewcell? Premium Article

    Renewcell was the darling of circular fashion this time last year, establishing an industrial scale flagship factory at Sundsvall, Sweden, while most of its next gen materials rivals were barely out of the lab. But, a year on from launching the…
  • Friday, 27 October 2023

    Q&A - next gen vs recycled leather Premium Article

    Searches for next gen leather alternatives have grabbed the attention of those keen to find a more sustainable alternative to animal-based leather in recent years. H&M has featured the cactus-based leather of Mexican company Desserto while Zara has…
  • Thursday, 12 October 2023

    Managing customer allergies to textile chemicals Premium Article

    Managing customer allergies to minute quantities of textile chemicals is far from simple and the industry must accept that a zero issue situation is impossible. Sometimes it’s easy to establish cause and effect, sometimes it’s easy to conclusively…
  • Wednesday, 11 October 2023

    Why risk should equal reward for suppliers Premium Article

    The textile industry is made up of all sorts of manufacturers, each with their own focus and approach. On one end of the spectrum are smaller mills that operate under short-term goals, driven by immediate client needs, market trends and the…
  • Tuesday, 10 October 2023

    Regulation drives next gen fibre interest Premium Article

    An entirely new category of European-created textile fibres is rapidly emerging based on reclaiming textile waste and its global influence could be huge. At the same time, it’s claimed this move could go a considerable way towards reversing some of…
  • Monday, 09 October 2023

    The tough choices facing brands in Myanmar Premium Article

    As human rights continue to deteriorate in Myanmar, more and more global brands are putting a halt on sourcing from the country. But what about the garment workers left behind? Swedish fashion giant H&M finally announced that it is to stop sourcing…
  • Friday, 06 October 2023

    Independent Higg tools review unpacked Premium Article

    The much-anticipated, KPMG-led technical review of the Sustainable Apparel Coalition's Higg MSI and PM tools has been finally released. It was back in June 2022 that the Sustainable Apparel Coalition (SAC) announced it was commissioning an…
  • Friday, 25 August 2023

    Purifying the textile waste stream Premium Article

    Using artificial intelligence to extract trims, zips and buttons to create clean textile feedstock, a Belgian company at the recent ITMA in Milan may have solved how to close the gap between textile sorting and recycling. Although precise global…
  • Monday, 21 August 2023

    Brave new world(ly) - Higg rebrand interview Premium Article

    "You can't use that," laughs James Schaffer, after tripping over 'Worldly' - the rebranded new name of the Higg technology company which runs the Higg Index suite of tools for the Sustainable Apparel Coalition (SAC) and is now branching out with new…
  • Monday, 21 August 2023

    The loops of textile circularity Premium Article

    Various debates have cynically unpicked the efforts of brands and retailers in a bid to disprove the viability of the concept of circularity, or more so to uncover the true motives behind these circular endeavours.Often these reports and articles…
  • Thursday, 17 August 2023

    How Shein and Temu ‘evade restrictions’ Premium Article

    WASHINGTON – US legislators are concerned that Chinese ultra-fast fashion retailers, like Shein and Temu, are out-flanking the Uyghur Forced Labor Prevention Act (UFLPA) which bans imports from Xinjiang on the assumption they are made with forced…
  • Thursday, 17 August 2023

    Coercive cotton labour to persist in Xinjiang Premium Article

    Forced labour is still widespread in the cotton industry of the Xinjiang region of China, despite Beijing's claims to the contrary, argues the first research on the subject that was recently published in a peer-reviewed journal. China's mass…
  • Friday, 04 August 2023

    Shedding the textile microfibre narrative Premium Article

    When it comes to fibre fragmentation, the existing narrative suggests that recycled polyester fabrics fair worse than those made with virgin polyester. However, Dr Kelly Sheridan, co-author of a recent report from the Microfibre Consortium (TMC),…
  • Wednesday, 02 August 2023

    Interview: Textile fibre pollution Premium Article

    Nearly two decades have elapsed since UK researchers published a seminal paper on tiny particles polluting the oceans. David Styles asks professor Richard Thompson OBE – a prize winning scientist in this field – how he reflects on the intervening…
  • Monday, 31 July 2023

    Time out for sustainable textile materials? Premium Article

    The elusive pursuit of sustainable new materials is unfolding at a pace more tortoise than hare, says Rogier van Mazijk, fund manager at the Textile Innovation Fund, who also believes that while numerous innovation categories have demonstrated…
  • Wednesday, 26 July 2023

    Eco-dyeing and finishing advances Premium Article

    Phil Patterson gives readers an insight into new innovations in printing, dyeing and general textile wet processing innovations seen at ITMA – where for him – one particular energy-saving idea was worth the time and expense of travelling to the…
  • Tuesday, 25 July 2023

    Focus on emerging technologies at ITMA Premium Article

    Start-Up Valley, a new feature at the 2023 ITMA trade show, featured 16 emerging companies hoping to scale new and game changing solutions and technologies. They included Dublin-based Tailr which is working on ways to harness the power of artificial…
  • Monday, 24 July 2023

    Many ITMA visitors miss out at Planet Textiles Premium Article

    Tens of thousands of ITMA visitors missed the opportunity to engage with key stakeholders on environmental issues in Milan – but they won’t be able to turn a deaf ear forever. ITMA 2023 was billed as the most sustainable ITMA event yet – if such an…
  • Monday, 26 June 2023

    Designing out the waste Premium Article

    The fashion industry is big, bold, and as messy as ever, but today it's having to face its critics over the harm that it continues to cause through its wasteful actions. However, can the industry re-design itself to re-define itself, and can it turn…
  • Tuesday, 20 June 2023

    Digital data exchange Premium Article

    The European Outdoor Group (EOG) and the German Federal Association of the German Sporting Goods Industry (BSI) have teamed up to launch the ‘Sustainability Data Exchange Project’, which aims to harmonise the exchange of product level sustainability…
  • Tuesday, 06 June 2023

    Q&A ... with Trove founder Andy Ruben Premium Article

    Andy Ruben, the founder and executive chairman of resale platform Trove, talks about why he left the retail giant Walmart to enter the resale space and gives readers a unique insight into what the future may hold for global resale as it continues to…
  • Friday, 02 June 2023

    Sew far, sew good Premium Article

    Funding new textile technologies requires more corporate interest if a repeat of the clean tech bubble burst of the late 2000s is to be avoided, argues Rogier van Mazijk, Fund Manager at Textile Innovation Fund. Over the last decade, numerous…
  • Wednesday, 31 May 2023

    Polymer biodegradation depends on local habitats Premium Article

    CHRISTCHURCH – In a conversation with textile technologist Colleen Ahalt-Eagle at the Performance Days trade show in Munich, she told Ecotextile News that her laboratory forensic work on synthetic fibre breakdown in New Zealand showed that existing,…
  • Caroline Priebe, LinkedIn
    Wednesday, 17 May 2023

    Sustainable fashion design Q & A with Caroline Priebe Premium Article

    Brooklyn-based Caroline Priebe is a US sustainable fashion designer with two decades of experience under her belt, so Tom Bithell caught up with her for a quick Q&A about her ideas on designing for true sustainability. Q: How is a garment…
  • Thursday, 27 April 2023

    Making climate adaptation a reality for farmers Premium Article

    Last summer’s floods in Pakistan displaced seven million people, caused a death toll of over 1,500 and damages of an estimated $30 billion, with only $5.6 billion covered by insurance. As just one instance of the increasing number of extreme weather…
  • Thursday, 20 April 2023

    Why biodegradability isn't always the answer Premium Article

    The promotion of biodegradation and biodegradability is being used to assuage consumer guilt associated with over-production and the ‘buy-use-dump model’ for both chemicals and clothing. There are three things that are clear about drawing…
  • Wednesday, 12 April 2023

    Surprise rise in garment exports from Myanmar Premium Article

    Amidst growing calls for fashion brands and retailers to consider pulling out of sourcing from Myanmar, World Bank figures reveal that garment exports from the country actually shot up for much of last year. Reports that exports of garments from…
Back Issue Archive
Other Publications from MCL News & Media

Interested in advertising?

Simply give us a call

Sales: +44 1977 708488

Or if you prefer email, click on the button below and we'll get back to you asap